Combat Doctrine

It’s D&D time. Your character is fresh off a long rest, all your class features are available, hit points are full, spell slots are open. The GM says those three little words players* love to hear - “Roll for Initiative” - as they place a squad of minis, tokens, or standees around the battle map.

What do you do? How do you decide what to do on your turn? How much confidence do you have that you made the right choice?

Let’s break down the problem and develop a system for analyzing and responding to battlefield threats.

Every every game, regardless of title, rules engine, or format, is first and foremost a system. Every system, from the very simple up to the most complex, a collection of parts. The challenge for us is to identify the parts that make up D&D combat and decide how important they are to us.

Parts of Combat

D&D combat happens over one or more rounds, with each round made up of each of the combatants taking a turn in which they are - mostly - given the exclusive right to act. The order of turns is determined by each combatant’s Initiative score. Players (including the GM, because they’re a player, too) decide and declare how their combatants act. The activities that each combatant is capable of are defined by a combination of their species, class, and the game system itself. Each of those activities falls into one of the following categories: Movement, Action, Bonus Action, or Reaction.

Let’s distill that paragraph to a list of parts, though. We have a combat made up of:

  • One or more rounds of…
  • Turns directed by…
  • Players deciding their characters’…
  • Activities, which might be…
  • Movement, Action, Bonus Action, or Reaction

That looks like D&D combat to me, but there is one other part to point out. Combatants aren’t allowed to simply keep acting on their turn; there are limits. Combatants are only allowed a maximum of one each of an Action, a Bonus Action, or a Reaction each round; their per-round Movement is limited by their Speed; they may only use Actions and Bonus Actions on their own turn; and Reactions may only be used during another combatant’s turn, and only under specific conditions. These limitations apply to all of the combatants.

Taken all together, the parts and the limits form the action economy of the combat system. Encounters are usually designed so that the non-GM players control their own characters while the GM controls all of the other combatants, and these factions are usually constructed provide the non-GM players with a balanced challenge. Exactly what constitutes a “balanced challenge” depends on the purpose of the encounter, but the intent is that combatants are not so wildly mismatched in capabilities that the combat is tedious, trivial, or hopeless.

Encounter design guides, from the Dungeon Master’s Guide (DMG) to your neighbor’s gaming blog (hi there!) includes some consideration of balancing the experience. The specific guidance and preferences in each source vary widely, but the general attitude runs toward “combat that’s too easy is boring, too hard kills the party.” Contributors may not agree on a precise difficulty formula, but they at least agree that ending the adventure by intentionally killing the other players’ characters is just as unwelcome as spending dozens of hours killing rats in village basements.

D&D helps encounter designers balance encounters by assigning its monsters a challenge rating (CR) that, to some extent, approximates what that monster’s level would be if it were a player character. In a slight regression, the 2024 DMG is less forthcoming with than the 2014 book concerning monster creation and CR assignment. The DMG24 advises how to take an existing, “close enough” configuration from the Monster Manual and alter its particulars without dramatically changing its overall power. DMG14, on the other, demonstrates a combination of HP and damage-per-round as the basis for CR assignment. The newer book may feel like a step backward, but the old system rarely worked well for complex monster creation and required extensive testing and calibration to ensure that custom-built monsters didn’t compromise encounter balance.

The importance of balance raises a conundrum: In a balanced combat, how can one group of combatants be assured of victory or, at least, survival?

Comparative Advantage

They can’t.
D&D depends on randomness, and sometimes the dice disfavor one combatant or faction for just long enough to create an insurmountable imbalance. Success cannot be guaranteed. This is the Picard Principle in action: “It is possible to make no mistakes and still lose. That is not a weakness; that is [D&D].”

Success cannot be guaranteed, but it can be optimized toward.

Players often assume, especially early in their gaming experience, that there is some perfect or ideal “build” for their character. They assiduously examine class features and select for more HP and damage-per-round output. This is not altogether ineffective and it certainly isn’t wrong - this is exactly the formula the DMG14 gives us for determining monster power! The result is a character that is optimized to “solve” combat with brute force alone. As long as opponents lose HP faster than allies do, then the allies will (probably) prevail. Brute force is a doctrine that can work well but fails poorly, and that failure usually causes a premature end to the adventure.

Earlier, we described the combat action economy, then we took a look at the importance of designing balanced encounters and one way that players might try to gain an advantage over their opponents by optimizing for character power. Unfortunately, the Qui-Gon Jinn Conjecture - to wit, “there is always a bigger fish” - consistently counters brute force. Since strength of arms alone cannot save us, we need to find another road; we need to go somewhere else in order to find a consistent, reliable means of maximizing combat effectiveness.

We’re going to dive into the world of economics but let’s skip the Econ lectures, except to say this much: economics is a social science that, to the dismay of its priestly classes, tries to describe the squishy, inconstant behaviors that emerge at the intersection of quantitative and qualitative factors. Given the tremendous suffering and stupidity economists have birthed into public policy, I’m not willing to be gracious toward them. Milton Friedman is one of the history’s great villains and any just society would rightly prise his useful contributions off of his execrable legacy of supply-side looterism before incinerating his memory… for sanitation.

Got that out of my system. For now. Back to the business at hand.

There are three types of advantage that economists generally talk about: absolute, competitive, and comparative. In simplest terms, here’s how each of these terms relates to D&D combat:

  • Absolute advantage - outproduce everyone else. In game terms, this basically amounts to having more HP and damage output, and probably requires simply being several levels higher. An eighth level Fighter has an absolute advantage over a Giant Rat. This is the brute force approach mentioned previously.
  • Competitive advantage - outperform others in a specific way. In-game, this might show up as a Bard with Expertise in multiple skills, a Barbarian’s damage resistances from Rage, or players who meticulously plan and execute ambushes.
  • Comparative advantage - realize major gains from minimizing opportunity costs and finding other ways to make up what’s missing. The in-game applications of this are about to get a lot more coverage, keep reading.

Those explanations got more complex as they went, and that basically tracks the development of the ideas themselves. Turns out, people generally look for more nuanced, effective, consistent solutions than “git gud” across all our activities, not just money and gaming.

“Opportunity cost” is a term that seems a lot more complicated that it really is. Basically, no one can be in two places at once, and no one can do multiple things at the exact same time. When you choose to do a thing (like, say, play D&D), the opportunity cost of that choice is all of the things that you might have been doing or experiencing during that time. For a lot of us, the opportunity cost of “going to a job” is equal to “literally anything enjoyable” - in spite of that, we choose “going to a job” because the benefits of that choice (damn well better) outweigh the cost of missing all those other things. Economists would tell parents that the choice to suffer through a kid’s choir recital, rather than go to a ripping good D&D game, is because that parent values their child more highly than they do a less suck-filled experience with grown-ups. The opportunity cost of a thing is everything that can’t be done while doing that thing.

How, exactly, does a combatant leverage this “comparative advantage” idea? Why not just stick with the, much simpler, absolute or competitive advantages?

Brute force, absolute advantage only works as long as the combatant is the hardiest, deadliest combatant (or party). A few bad rolls of the dice, a higher-powered boss, or a numerical advantage on the field all quickly reverse an absolute advantage.

Resistances, tactical positioning, and other relative advantages are at least more reliable than brute force. They’ll help smooth out fickle luck and can overcome an opponent’s brute force, but are vulnerable to changes of circumstance. Competitive advantages, in RPG combat, largely amount to fighting from a fixed position: the defender must execute perfectly every time, the attacker only needs to get lucky once.

Comparative advantage is the true underdog tactic, while not being the exclusive purview of the disadvantaged. A combatant leveraging comparative advantages works to optimize the ratio of their own opportunity costs relative to their opponent’s. Let’s put that in human language: focus on doing the simplest things you can to disrupt your enemy’s ability to do anything.

If that seems obvious or straightforward, it’s because you’re incredibly clever. Congrats.

For the rest of us, the sorts of tactics that build or leverage a comparative battlefield advantage - the sort that can overcome powerful, unpredictable foes - include:

  • control or restrict points of ingress and egress
  • limit enemy area-of-effect
  • reduce enemy headcount
  • minimize the enemy’s ability to hit or target
  • maximize allied activity
  • “focused fire”

These tactics share a common, unifying concept: control the action economy. Look, I didn’t spend entirely too much time expounding on action economy and economic concepts for my own enjoyment, there was a point to it: the balance of power in any encounter leans toward whoever best exploits its overall economy. A large number of weak opponents can overwhelm a more powerful combatant (see: “Zerg rush”), even if they sustain heavy casualties.

There is no singular “comparative advantage” tactic to employ. Instead, players and parties should cultivate an overall strategic philosophy, a doctrine of engagement that centers and manipulates the overall action economy. The combat encounters are designed to emphasize balance, and to equalize the absolute advantage of the party against groups of similarly-enabled enemies. Under these circumstances the party that can reduce, contain, or minimize its opponents’ ability to act - especially when the party can gain action supremacy - may not necessarily prevail, but will reliably out-perform its adversaries.

The Sergeant Zim Principle

“The enemy cannot push a button if you disable its hand”
This principle was first articulated in the context of a nuclear-powered opponent launching an attack of absolute destructive power. Sergeant Zim elegantly demonstrates one method by which such a threat can be rendered impotent.

This principle also applies to D&D combat. A party that can reliably, consistently limit its opponents’ ability to act, to constrain their engagement with the action economy, will enjoy greater success, while expending fewer resources, than a party that emphasizes raw, brute force power.